What to do on an acre (6)

Two euro- acres: upper image, Plaza de Platerías (A) and Plaza de la Quintana (B), lower image the New national Gallery in Berlin, close to the Sankt Matthaus church (C) and by the Postdamer Strasse (D)

Two euro- acres: upper image, Plaza de Platerías (A) and Plaza de la Quintana (B) in Santiago de Compostela, Spain, and lower image the New national Gallery in Berlin, close to the Sankt Matthaus church (C) and by the Postdamer Strasse (D)

An acre can be an opened or a close surface, or something in between. The squares around the eastern flank of the Cathedral of Santiago are the result of a set of circunstances: a complex natural slope, the previous presence of a cemetery, the presence of monastic buildings… This makes for a set of spaces enclosed by strong institutions, which have grown in power throught time with a magnificent architecture, whose expresion has sometimes been baroque, and in other moments quite austere, with new proposals in the interiors like the fine project by BMJ for Casa da Conga.

Plaza de la Quintana from the North

Plaza de la Quintana from the North

In Berlin, on the other side, the combined surface of both Spanish squares is covered by … well, a square slab, supported on eight steel columns (the building has a larger basement, but it is scarcely visible from the outside, its presence resting on the upper part). The building, by the great master Mies Van der Rohe, is a space whose enclosure is defined first by the large slab itself, and also by a glass curtain on an inner position. There are no obstacles to view the outside and, for instance, Sankt Matthaus church, the Philarmonie or the Sony Plaza. When I visited the Galerie in 2011, it was empty but for a large cylindrical installation. The building is elegant in proportions, but so nude of ornament that any rust mark or any reminder of the complexity of reality is simply too apparent. Opose that to the Santiago squares, all with a granite which has suffered the passage of time. As in the case of the large ships carrying oil derricks, this a matter of a play of spaces and scale relations, in each case with a different result.

The Berlin Galerie as seen from Postdamer Strasse

The Berlin Galerie as seen from Postdamer Strasse

Platerías looking to the North

Platerías looking to the North

The Sankt Matthaus Church as seen from the Galerie

The Sankt Matthaus Church as seen from the Galerie

The outer skin of the Galerie. A clean architecture, with a slender yet imposing column... accompanied by an ashtray/bin (thank god, at least black)

The outer skin of the Galerie. A clean architecture, with a slender yet imposing column… accompanied by an ashtray/bin (thank god, at least black)

The northern part of Quintana

The northern part of Quintana

Your empty space to play with

Your empty space to play with

A view towards the east from Platerias

A view towards the east from Platerias

2 comments

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s